对 Scientific Reports 2, 674 中“线性无源硅光隔离器”的评论
光学
2013-01-31 v1
摘要
Wang 等人 [1] 在模拟和实验中展示了正向和反向传播具有不同的功率传输系数。基于此演示，他们论文的核心主张是“空间反演对称性破缺二极管可以构建光隔离器，且不与任何互易原理冲突”。他们的主张与洛伦兹互易定理相矛盾，根据该定理众所周知无法以此方式构建隔离器。
引用
@article{arxiv.1301.7243,
title = {Comment on "Linear and passive silicon optical isolator" in Scientific Reports 2, 674},
author = {Alexander Petrov and Dirk Jalas and Manfred Eich and Wolfgang Freude and Shanhui Fan and Zongfu Yu and Roel Baets and Miloš Popović and Andrea Melloni and John D. Joannopoulos and Mathias Vanwolleghem and Christopher R. Doerr and Hagen Renner},
journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1301.7243},
year = {2013}
}