Comment on "Taleyarkhan et al. Reply:"
综合物理
2007-05-23 v1 核实验
核理论
数据分析、统计与概率
摘要
In their Reply to my previous Comment, Taleyarkhan and coauthors measure their detectors' responses to a Cf-252 source, concluding that the resulting spectra differ substantially from the cavitation-fusion spectra published earlier in their Letter. On the contrary, I conclude that the two data sets are qualitatively consistent.
引用
@article{arxiv.physics/0702009,
title = {Comment on "Taleyarkhan et al. Reply:"},
author = {B. Naranjo},
journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:physics/0702009},
year = {2007}
}
备注
1 page, 2 figures, comment regarding Taleyarkhan et al., PRL 97 149404 (2006), will not be published because PRL's policy is to not consider a Comment on a Reply