The homotopy theory of complete modules

Given a commutative ring $R$ and finitely generated ideal $I$, one can consider the classes of $I$-adically complete, $L_0^I$-complete and derived $I$-complete complexes. Under a mild assumption on the ideal $I$ called weak pro-regularity, these three notions of completions interact well. We consider the classes of $I$-adically complete, $L_0^I$-complete and derived $I$-complete complexes and prove that they present the same homotopy theory. Given a ring homomorphism $R \to S$, we then give necessary and sufficient conditions for the categories of complete $R$-complexes and the categories of complete $S$-complexes to have equivalent homotopy theories. This recovers and generalizes a result of Sather-Wagstaff and Wicklein on extended local (co)homology.