Conclusive nonlinear phase sensitivity limit for a Mach-Zehnder interferometer with single-mode non-vacuum inputs

Many works have stated that nonlinear interactions can improve phase sensitivity beyond the Heisenberg limit scaling of $1/N$ with $N$ being the mean photon number. This raises some open questions---among them the conclusive sensitivity limits with respect to single-mode inputs. Namely, when one of two inputs is vacuum, is there a shot-noise-style sensitivity bound on a nonlinear Mach-Zehnder interferometer? Within the reach of second-order nonlinear phase shifts, we make an attempt to provide an answer to this question. Based upon phase-averaging approach, this puzzle is partially resolved with careful calculations of the quantum Fisher information regarding three kinds of common inputs: Gaussian states, squeezed number states, and Schr\"odinger cat states. The results suggest that shot-noise-style sensitivity limit is no longer available, and the ideal candidate is squeezed vacuum.