Towards Optimal Output-Sensitive Clique Listing or: Listing Cliques from Smaller Cliques

We study finding and listing $k$-cliques in a graph, for constant $k\geq 3$, a fundamental problem of both theoretical and practical importance. Our main contribution is a new output-sensitive algorithm for listing $k$-cliques in graphs, for arbitrary $k\geq 3$, coupled with lower bounds based on standard fine-grained assumptions, showing that our algorithm's running time is tight. Previously, the only known conditionally optimal output-sensitive algorithms were for the case of $3$-cliques by Bj\"{o}rklund, Pagh, Vassilevska W. and Zwick [ICALP'14]. Typical inputs to subgraph isomorphism or listing problems are measured by the number of nodes $n$ or the number of edges $m$. Our framework is very general in that it gives $k$-clique listing algorithms whose running times are measured in terms of the number of $\ell$-cliques $\Delta_\ell$ in the graph for any $1\leq \ell<k$. This generalizes the typical parameterization in terms of $n$ (the number of $1$-cliques) and $m$ (the number of $2$-cliques). If the matrix multiplication exponent $\omega$ is $2$, and if the size of the output, $\Delta_k$, is sufficiently large, then for every $\ell<k$, the running time of our algorithm for listing $k$-cliques is $$\tilde{O}\left(\Delta_\ell^{\frac{2}{\ell (k - \ell)}}\Delta_k^{1-\frac{2}{k(k-\ell)}}\right).$$ For sufficiently large $\Delta_k$, we prove that this runtime is in fact {\em optimal} for all $1 \leq \ell < k$ under the Exact $k$-Clique hypothesis. In the special cases of $k = 4$ and $5$, our algorithm in terms of $n$ is conditionally optimal for all values of $\Delta_k$ if $\omega = 2$. Moreover, our framework is powerful enough to provide an improvement upon the 19-year old runtimes for $4$ and $5$-clique detection in $m$-edge graphs, as a function of $m$ [Eisenbrand and Grandoni, TCS'04].