English

Three steps away from Shapiro's problem: lower bounds for graphic sums with functions `max' or `min' in denominators

Combinatorics 2021-06-22 v1 Classical Analysis and ODEs

Abstract

Taking Shapiro's cyclic sums i=1nxi/(xi+1+xi+2)\sum_{i=1}^n x_i/(x_{i+1}+x_{i+2}) (assuming index addition mod nn) as a starting point, we introduce a broader class of cyclic sums, called generalized Shapiro-Diananda sums, where the denominators are pp-th order power means of the sets {xi+j1,,xi+jk}\{x_{i+j_1},\dots,x_{i+j_k}\} with fixed distinct integers j1,,jkj_1,\dots,j_k and 1in1\leq i\leq n. Generalizing further, we replace the set of arguments of the power mean in the ii-th denominator by an arbitrary nonempty subset of {1,,n}\{1,\dots,n\} interpreted as the set of out-neighbors of the node number ii in a directed graph with nn nodes. We call such sums graphic power sums since their structure is controlled by directed graphs. The inquiry, as in the well-researched case of Shapiro's sums, concerns the greatest lower bound of the given ``sum'' as a function of positive variables x1,,xnx_1,\dots,x_n. We show that the cases of p=+p=+\infty (max-sums) and p=p=-\infty (min-sums) are tractable. For the max-sum associated with a given graph the g.l.b. is always an integer; for a strongly connected graph it equals to graph's girth. For the similar min-sum, we could not relate the g.l.b. to a known combinatorial invariant; we only give some estimates and describe a method for finding the g.l.b., which has factorial complexity in nn. A satisfactory analytical treatment is available for the secondary minimization -- when the g.l.b.'s of min-sums for individual graphs are mininized over the class of strongly connected graphs with nn nodes. The result (depending only on nn) is found to be asymptotic to elnne\ln n.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2106.10877,
  title  = {Three steps away from Shapiro's problem: lower bounds for graphic sums with functions `max' or `min' in denominators},
  author = {Sergey Sadov},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2106.10877},
  year   = {2021}
}

Comments

37 pages, 2 figures