Small atoms fall into bulk from non-close-packed surfaces?

Surface rippling has been observed when atoms of $X$ and $A$ are mixed on the $A$ substrate surface. The rippling amplitude has been estimated using hard sphere models. We present a gedanken experiment predicting a penetration of small atoms into bulk through the (100) surface. To understand how the electronic effects alter this picture, we investigate the surface rippling of $X/A(100)$ from first-principles, assuming $X=$ H to Bi except for noble gases and $A=$ Cu, Ag, and Au. We show that the small atoms (such as H, C, N, O and F) attract electrons from the substrate due to the large electronegativity, which prevent them from passing through the void in the (100) surface. The behaviors of small atoms are further explored by studying lateral displacements of the top layer in the $A$ substrate and a formation of the $X$ dimer above, below, and across the top layer. The present work provides an example to understand when atoms are not hard spheres.