English

On computation with 'probabilities' modulo k

Computational Complexity 2014-12-24 v2 Quantum Physics

Abstract

We propose a framework to study models of computation of indeterministic data, represented by abstract "distributions". In these distributions, probabilities are replaced by "amplitudes" drawn from a fixed semi-ring SS, of which the non-negative reals, the complex numbers, finite fields Fpr\mathbb F_{p^r}, and cyclic rings Zk\mathbb Z_k are examples. Varying SS yields different models of computation, which we may investigate to better understand the (likely) difference in power between randomised and quantum computation. The "modal quantum states" of Schumacher and Westmoreland [arXiv:1010.2929] are examples of such distributions, for SS a finite field. For S=F2S = \mathbb F_2, Willcock and Sabry [arXiv:1102.3587] show that UNIQUE-SAT is solvable by polynomial-time uniform circuit families consisting of invertible gates. We characterize the decision problems solvable by polynomial uniform circuit families, using either invertible or "unitary" transformations over cyclic rings S=ZkS = \mathbb Z_k, or (in the case that kk is a prime power) finite fields S=FkS = \mathbb F_k. In particular, for kk a prime power, these are precisely the problems in the class ModkP\mathsf{Mod}_k\mathsf P.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.1405.7381,
  title  = {On computation with 'probabilities' modulo k},
  author = {Niel de Beaudrap},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1405.7381},
  year   = {2014}
}

Comments

53 pages, 3 figures. Simplified to focus on cyclic rings. New content includes a treatment of "affine" state spaces and bounded-error computation, and an argument (Appendix C) to allow certain infinite gate-sets in the study of quantum algorithms. Many minor technical errors also corrected. Keywords: counting complexity, destructive interference, indeterminism, modal quantum theory

R2 v1 2026-06-22T04:25:33.764Z