English

$\mathrm{TIME}[t]\subseteq \mathrm{SPACE}[O(\sqrt{t})]$ via Tree Height Compression

Computational Complexity 2026-01-05 v4 Artificial Intelligence Data Structures and Algorithms

Abstract

We prove a square-root space simulation for deterministic multitape Turing machines, showing TIME[t]SPACE[O(t)]\mathrm{TIME}[t]\subseteq \mathrm{SPACE}[O(\sqrt{t})] \emph{measured in tape cells over a fixed finite alphabet}. The key step is a Height Compression Theorem that uniformly (and in logspace) reshapes the canonical left-deep succinct computation tree for a block-respecting run into a binary tree whose evaluation-stack depth along any DFS path is O(logT)O(\log T) for T=t/bT=\lceil t/b\rceil, while preserving O(b)O(b) workspace at leaves and O(1)O(1) at internal nodes. Edges have \emph{addressing/topology} checkable in O(logt)O(\log t) space, and \emph{semantic} correctness across merges is witnessed by an exact O(b)O(b) bounded-window replay at the unique interface. Algorithmically, an Algebraic Replay Engine with constant-degree maps over a constant-size field, together with pointerless DFS, index-free streaming, and a \emph{rolling boundary buffer that prevents accumulation of leaf summaries}, ensures constant-size per-level tokens and eliminates wide counters, yielding the additive tradeoff S(b)=O(b+t/b)S(b)=O(b+t/b). Choosing b=Θ(t)b=\Theta(\sqrt{t}) gives O(t)O(\sqrt{t}) space with no residual multiplicative polylog factors. The construction is uniform, relativizes, and is robust to standard model choices. Consequences include branching-program upper bounds 2O(s)2^{O(\sqrt{s})} for size-ss bounded-fan-in circuits, tightened quadratic-time lower bounds for SPACE[n]\mathrm{SPACE}[n]-complete problems via the standard hierarchy argument, and O(t)O(\sqrt{t})-space certifying interpreters; under explicit locality assumptions, the framework extends to geometric dd-dimensional models. Conceptually, the work isolates path bookkeeping as the chief obstruction to O(t)O(\sqrt{t}) and removes it via structural height compression with per-path analysis rather than barrier-prone techniques.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2508.14831,
  title  = {$\mathrm{TIME}[t]\subseteq \mathrm{SPACE}[O(\sqrt{t})]$ via Tree Height Compression},
  author = {Logan Nye},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2508.14831},
  year   = {2026}
}

Comments

The proof of the main theorem is incorrect. In Sections 2-4, the paper's height-compression/evaluation framework assumes an interval-based associative summary tree that does not correctly model the Tree Evaluation instances/dependencies arising in Williams's simulation

R2 v1 2026-07-01T04:58:41.624Z