English

Contextuality offers security

Quantum Physics 2010-06-08 v2

Abstract

The discovery of quantum key distribution by Bennett and Brassard (BB84) bases on the fundamental quantum feature: incompatibility of measurements of quantum non-commuting observables. In 1991 Ekert showed that cryptographic key can be generated at a distance with help of entangled (correlated) quantum particles. Recently Barrett, Hardy and Kent showed that the non-locality used by Ekert is itself a good resource of cryptographic key even beyond quantum mechanics. Their result paved the way to new generation of quantum cryptographic protocols - secure even if the devices are built by the very eavesdropper. However, there is a question, which is fundamental from both practical and philosophical point of view: does Nature offer security on operational level based on the original concept behind quantum cryptography - that information gain about one bservables must cause disturbance to another, incompatible one? Here we resolve this problem by using in place of non-locality another striking feature of quantum world - contextuality. It is a strong version of incompatibility manifested in the famous Kochen-Specker paradox. The crucial concept is the use of a new class of families of bipartite probability distributions which locally exhibit the Kochen-Specker paradox conditions and, in addition, exhibit perfect correlations. We show that if two persons share systems described by such a family then they can extract secure key. This is the first operational protocol that directly implements the fundamental feature of Nature: the information gain vs. disturbance trade-off. At the same time it provides natural device-independent cryptographic scheme within quantum mechanics suitable for current technology.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.1002.2410,
  title  = {Contextuality offers security},
  author = {Karol Horodecki and Michal Horodecki and Pawel Horodecki and Ryszard Horodecki and Marcin Pawlowski and Mohamed Bourennane},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1002.2410},
  year   = {2010}
}

Comments

This paper has been withdrawn by the authors due to crucial error in the proof. A significantly revised version has appeared as arXiv:1006.0468

R2 v1 2026-06-21T14:46:10.138Z