English

Can a falling tree make a noise in two forests at the same time?

Quantum Physics 2007-05-23 v2 Atomic Physics

Abstract

It is a commonplace to claim that quantum mechanics supports the old idea that a tree falling in a forest makes no sound unless there is a listener present. In fact, this conclusion is far from obvious. Furthermore, if a tunnelling particle is observed in the barrier region, it collapses to a state in which it is no longer tunnelling. Does this imply that while tunnelling, the particle can not have any physical effects? I argue that this is not the case, and moreover, speculate that it may be possible for a particle to have effects on two spacelike separate apparatuses simultaneously. I discuss the measurable consequences of such a feat, and speculate about possible statistical tests which could distinguish this view of quantum mechanics from a ``corpuscular'' one. Brief remarks are made about an experiment underway at Toronto to investigate these issues.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.quant-ph/9710046,
  title  = {Can a falling tree make a noise in two forests at the same time?},
  author = {Aephraim M. Steinberg},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:quant-ph/9710046},
  year   = {2007}
}

Comments

9 pp, Latex, 3 figs, to appear in Proc. Obsc. Unr. Conf.; Fig 2 postscript repaired on 26.10.97