English

Spurious causality hiding an action at a distance

Classical Physics 2010-12-03 v2

Abstract

The Coulomb/Gauss law given in the Maxwell equations describes a spatial relation between the electric field component E(r,t)E_\parallel({\bf r}, t) and its source ρ(r,t)\rho({\bf r}, t) that is instantaneous, occurring at the same time tt. This instantaneous action at a distance can be hidden by writing it formally as the sum of two causal terms. I show here that the causal expression of the total electric field E{\bf E} suffers from such a spurious causality hiding the action at a distance that is EE_\parallel. In fact, EE_\parallel remains instantaneous in time even when it is part of a wave equation. Only the E{\bf E}_\perp part is really causal.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.1011.4541,
  title  = {Spurious causality hiding an action at a distance},
  author = {Chun Wa Wong},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1011.4541},
  year   = {2010}
}

Comments

Expanded to 9 pages

R2 v1 2026-06-21T16:46:27.621Z