Sharp $H^1$-norm error estimates of two time-stepping schemes for reaction-subdiffusion problems

Due to the intrinsically initial singularity of solution and the discrete convolution form in numerical Caputo derivatives, the traditional $H^1$-norm analysis (corresponding to the case for a classical diffusion equation) to the time approximations of a fractional subdiffusion problem always leads to suboptimal error estimates (a loss of time accuracy). To recover the theoretical accuracy in time, we propose an improved discrete Gr\"{o}nwall inequality and apply it to the well-known L1 formula and a fractional Crank-Nicolson scheme. With the help of a time-space error-splitting technique and the global consistency analysis, sharp $H^1$-norm error estimates of the two nonuniform approaches are established for a reaction-subdiffusion problems. Numerical experiments are included to confirm the sharpness of our analysis.