Identifying codes in graphs of given maximum degree: Characterizing trees

An identifying code of a closed-twin-free graph $G$ is a dominating set $S$ of vertices of $G$ such that any two vertices in $G$ have a distinct intersection between their closed neighborhoods and $S$. It was conjectured that there exists an absolute constant $c$ such that for every connected graph $G$ of order $n$ and maximum degree $\Delta$, the graph $G$ admits an identifying code of size at most $( \frac{\Delta-1}{\Delta} )n +c$. We provide significant support for this conjecture by exactly characterizing every tree requiring a positive constant $c$ together with the exact value of the constant. Hence, proving the conjecture for trees. For $\Delta=2$ (the graph is a path or a cycle), it is long known that $c=3/2$ suffices. For trees, for each $\Delta\ge 3$, we show that $c=1/\Delta\le 1/3$ suffices and that $c$ is required to have a positive value only for a finite number of trees. In particular, for $\Delta = 3$, there are 12 trees with a positive constant $c$ and, for each $\Delta \ge 4$, the only tree with positive constant $c$ is the $\Delta$-star. Our proof is based on induction and utilizes recent results from [F. Foucaud, T. Lehtil\"a. Revisiting and improving upper bounds for identifying codes. SIAM Journal on Discrete Mathematics, 2022]. We remark that there are infinitely many trees for which the bound is tight when $\Delta=3$; for every $\Delta\ge 4$, we construct an infinite family of trees of order $n$ with identification number very close to the bound, namely $\left( \frac{\Delta-1+\frac{1}{\Delta-2}}{\Delta+\frac{2}{\Delta-2}} \right) n > (\frac{\Delta-1}{\Delta} ) n -\frac{n}{\Delta^2}$. Furthermore, we also give a new tight upper bound for identification number on trees by showing that the sum of the domination and identification numbers of any tree $T$ is at most its number of vertices.