English

Comment on `Painlev\'e Integrability and Multi-wave pattern for (2+1) dimensional Long wave-Short wave Resonance Interaction system'

Exactly Solvable and Integrable Systems 2023-08-15 v1

Abstract

In the paper by Sivatharani et al [1], the authors make a tall claim about the integrability of a 2 component (2+1) dimensional Long wave Short wave Resonance Interaction (2C(2+1)LSRI) equation with mixed sign which was already claimed to be non integrable and hence known not to satisfy Painlev\'e [2] property which the authors show to pass Painlev\'e test. We have categorically shown how the system does not pass Painlev\'e test and hence non-integrable reinforcing the claim made by Maruno et al [2]. The authors claim to derive the solutions of 2C(2+1)LSRI equation which ironically do not satisfy the equation. To top it all, the authors claim to have generated lumps and dromions which again defy their very own definition.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2308.07043,
  title  = {Comment on `Painlev\'e Integrability and Multi-wave pattern for (2+1) dimensional Long wave-Short wave Resonance Interaction system'},
  author = {R. Radha and C. Senthil Kumar},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.07043},
  year   = {2023}
}

Comments

5 pages

R2 v1 2026-06-28T11:54:59.730Z