English

A cognitive basis for physical time

History and Philosophy of Physics 2024-11-12 v2

Abstract

The treatment of time in relativity does not conform to that in quantum theory. In the context of quantum gravity this is called "the problem of time". A crucial difference is that time tt may be seen as an observable in relativity theory, just like position xx, whereas in quantum theory tt is a parameter, in contrast to the observable xx. Aiming to resolve the discrepancy, a formalization of time in the spirit of Kant's Copernican revolution is suggested, where it is required that the treatment of time in physics agree with our cognition. This leads to reconsideration of the notions of identity and change of objects, as well as the nature of physical states and their evolution. The formalization has two components: sequential time nn and relational time tt. The evolution of physical states is described in terms of nn, which is updated each time an event occurs. The role of tt is to quantify distances between events in space-time. There is a space-time associated with each nn, in which tt represents the knowledge at time nn about temporal distances between present and past events. A universal ordering of events in terms of nn can be postulated even though distances tt are relativistic. In short, it is argued that time as a sequential flow of events should be separated from time as a measure of distance between events. In physical models, these aspects of time can be expressed as one evolution parameter and one observable, respectively.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2411.01427,
  title  = {A cognitive basis for physical time},
  author = {Per Östborn},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2411.01427},
  year   = {2024}
}

Comments

38 pages, 18 figures. The material in this paper is a further development of preliminary ideas expressed in a wider context in arXiv:1601.00680 and arXiv:1801.03396. Version 2: Reference inserted to the accompanying paper arxiv.org/abs/2411.02885

R2 v1 2026-06-28T19:46:11.697Z