English
Related papers

Related papers: Comment on "The inconvenient truth about flocks" b…

200 papers

We hereby reply concisely and hopefully clearly to the ongoing claims of incorrectness made by Chen et al. about our work on two-dimensional flocks.

Statistical Mechanics · Physics 2025-06-17 Hugues Chaté , Alexandre Solon

This is our response to the comment arXiv:2504.13683 posted by Chat\'e and Solon in reference to our preprint arXiv:2503.17064

Soft Condensed Matter · Physics 2025-05-29 Leiming Chen , Patrick Jentsch , Chiu Fan Lee , Ananyo Maitra , Sriram Ramaswamy , John Toner

We regret to point out several inaccurate and misleading statements that Benedetto {\em et al.} make in their Reply to our Comment on their paper titled ``Language Trees and Zipping''.

Statistical Mechanics · Physics 2007-05-23 Dmitry V. Khmelev , William J. Teahan

We analyze a recent pedagogical proposal for an alternative treatment of the angular part of the Schr\"odinger equation with a central potential. We show that the authors' arguments are unclear, unconvincing and misleading.

Quantum Physics · Physics 2010-02-16 Francisco M. Fernández

Comment on ``Demystifying Double Robustness: A Comparison of Alternative Strategies for Estimating a Population Mean from Incomplete Data'' [arXiv:0804.2958]

Methodology · Statistics 2008-12-18 Anastasios A. Tsiatis , Marie Davidian

Comment on ``Demystifying Double Robustness: A Comparison of Alternative Strategies for Estimating a Population Mean from Incomplete Data'' [arXiv:0804.2958]

Methodology · Statistics 2008-12-18 Greg Ridgeway , Daniel F. McCaffrey

Two recent papers (Renou et al., arXiv:2101.10873, and Chen et al., arXiv:2103.08123) have indicated that complex numbers are necessary for quantum theory. This short note is a comment on their result.

Quantum Physics · Physics 2021-03-25 J. Finkelstein

In our comment we show that some of the very difficult problems have been successfully solved. We have to focus on the resolved problems, since the authors claims: Our hope, however, is that the topics we have presented will provide…

Strongly Correlated Electrons · Physics 2025-12-23 V. R. Shaginyan , A. Z. Msezane

We criticize the originality or correctness of some of the ideas and results recently reported by Ng et al. in arXiv:1511.08546.

Optics · Physics 2016-05-20 Manuel Nieto-Vesperinas

After carefully studying the comment by Wang et al. (arXiv:1408.6420), we found it includes several mistakes and unjustified statements and Wang et al. lack very basic knowledge of dislocations. Moreover, there is clear evidence indicating…

Data Analysis, Statistics and Probability · Physics 2014-09-03 Jianwei Miao , M. C. Scott , Chien-Chun Chen , Chun Zhu , Edward R. White , Chin-Yi Chiu , B. C. Regan , Yu Huang , Laurence D. Marks

The various versions of cond-mat/0312353 discuss results obtained by me&coworkers in the last decade. I have received requests to comment on the paper and the comments are collected here, including some that I tried to point in the course…

Statistical Mechanics · Physics 2007-05-23 Giovanni Gallavotti

A comment has been recently posted on the arXiv (arXiv:1902.07504) that discuss our recent work on encircling multiple exceptional points in Nat. Commun. 9, 4808 (2018). In that comment, the authors claim that our approach is prone to…

Quantum Physics · Physics 2019-03-19 Q. Zhong , M. Khajavikhan , D. N. Christodoulides , R. El-Ganainy

We reply to comment on recent paper by Pieplow and Henkel (New J. Phys. 15 (2013) 023027) and our results made by Volokitin and Persson (arXiv: 1405.2525)

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics · Physics 2014-07-02 A. A. Kyasov , G. V. Dedkov

We revamp the existing theory of Euler class groups and present them in as much generality as possible. We remark on two results of Asok-Fasel and indicate some improvements.

Commutative Algebra · Mathematics 2019-01-31 Mrinal Kanti Das

We reanalyze the hydrodynamic theory of "flocks" that is, polar ordered "dry" active fluids in two dimensions. For "Malthusian" flocks, in which birth and death cause the density to relax quickly, thereby eliminating density as a…

Soft Condensed Matter · Physics 2025-04-01 Leiming Chen , Patrick Jentsch , Chiu Fan Lee , Ananyo Maitra , Sriram Ramaswamy , John Toner

In their comment on our work (ArXiv:1912.07056v1), Cavagna \textit{et al.} raise several interesting points on the phenomenology of flocks of birds, and conduct additional data analysis to back up their points. In particular, they question…

Statistical Mechanics · Physics 2019-12-23 Mathias Casiulis , Marco Tarzia , Leticia F. Cugliandolo , Olivier Dauchot

We make some comments about the results we obtained in Phys. Rev. Lett. 86,3392(2001), and in Phys. Rev. Lett.87, 177206 (2001), and show that the conclusion of a recent paper [cond-mat/0409495] leveling some criticism on our results is, in…

Strongly Correlated Electrons · Physics 2009-09-29 Bogdan A. Bernevig , Domenico Giuliano , Robert B. Laughlin

The paper titled ''Global gridded population datasets systematically underrepresent rural population'' by Josias L\'ang-Ritter et al. provides a valuable contribution to the discourse on the accuracy of global population datasets,…

Populations and Evolution · Quantitative Biology 2026-02-11 Till Koebe , Emmanuel Letouzé , Tuba Bircan , Édith Darin , Douglas R. Leasure , Valentina Rotondi

After the rejection of their comment [arXiv:cond-mat/0609399v1] to our Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 97}, 100601 (2006), the Authors informed us that an extended version of their comment is going to be published in a different journal under the…

Statistical Mechanics · Physics 2007-05-23 Fulvio Baldovin , Enzo Orlandini
‹ Prev 1 2 3 10 Next ›