English
Related papers

Related papers: A note on recent criticisms to Birnbaum's theorem

200 papers

The proofs of Theorem 3.1 and Corollary 4.1 in Le\~ao and Ohashi (2013) are incomplete. The reason is a wrong statement in Remark 2.2. The hypotheses and statements of Theorem 3.1 and Corollary 4.1 in Le\~ao and Ohashi (2013) remain…

Probability · Mathematics 2015-08-31 Dorival Leão , Alberto Ohashi

Bianchi and Don\`{a} [1] have recently reported a proof to the variance formula of von Neumann entropy, which was conjectured in [2] and firstly proved in [3]. The purpose of this short note is to show that, despite having a different…

Information Theory · Computer Science 2019-06-26 Lu Wei

We show that the theorems in Hansen (2021a) (the version accepted by Econometrica), except for one, are not new as they coincide with classical theorems like the good old Gauss-Markov or Aitken Theorem, respectively; the exceptional theorem…

Statistics Theory · Mathematics 2024-06-07 Benedikt M. Pötscher , David Preinerstorfer

This note was written in Jan. 23, 2015 to answer a problem raised by G. Moser, who asked a constructive proof of a theorem by Ferreira-Zantema.

Logic · Mathematics 2020-08-18 Toshiyasu Arai

In a recent note Ellis criticizes varying speed of light theories on the grounds of a number of foundational issues. His reflections provide us with an opportunity to clarify some fundamental matters pertaining to these theories.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology · Physics 2008-11-26 Joao Magueijo , John W. Moffat

In this paper we provide an application to the Neumann problem of a recent three critical points theorem.

Analysis of PDEs · Mathematics 2009-02-04 Biagio Ricceri

This note presents two ideas. The first one is that quantum theory has a fundamentally perturbative basis but leads to nonperturbative states which it would seem natural to take into account in the foundation of a theory of quantum…

Quantum Physics · Physics 2015-05-14 Claude Billionnet

Our objective in this note is to comment briefly on the newly emerging literature on computer-aided proofs in Social Choice Theory. We shall specifically comment on two papers, one by Tang and Lin (2009) and another by Geist and Endriss…

Logic in Computer Science · Computer Science 2014-03-17 Siddharth Chatterjee , Arunava Sen

In P\"otscher and Preinerstorfer (2022) and in the abridged version P\"otscher and Preinerstorfer (2024, published in Econometrica) we have tried to clear up the confusion introduced in Hansen (2022a) and in the earlier versions Hansen…

Econometrics · Economics 2024-06-10 Benedikt M. Pötscher

In this note we give two proofs of Brooks' Theorem. The first is obtained by modifying an earlier proof and the second by combining two earlier proofs. We believe these proofs are easier to teach in Computer Science courses.

Discrete Mathematics · Computer Science 2025-10-06 Gopalan Sajith , Sanjeev Saxena

We comment on the validity of Noether's theorem and on the conclusions of [J. Math. Phys. 61 (2020), no. 11, 113502].

Optimization and Control · Mathematics 2023-01-04 Delfim F. M. Torres

We give a proof of a result of Bonet, Engli\v{s} and Taskinen filling in several details and correcting some flaws.

Functional Analysis · Mathematics 2010-02-22 Sven-Ake Wegner

An analysis is made of Deutsch's recent claim to have derived the Born rule from decision-theoretic assumptions. It is argued that Deutsch's proof must be understood in the explicit context of the Everett interpretation, and that in this…

Quantum Physics · Physics 2007-05-23 David Wallace

We study \L o\'s's theorem in a choiceless context. We introduce some variants of \L o\'s's theorem. These variants seem weaker than \L o\'s's theorem, but we prove that these are equivalent to \L o\'s's theorem.

Logic · Mathematics 2025-01-28 Toshimichi Usuba

We consider some critical claims concerning our above paper, and reply to these claims.

Optimization and Control · Mathematics 2019-05-22 Andrei Dmitruk , Ivan Samylovskiy

Journe's Lemma is a critical component of many questions related to the product ${BMO}$ theory of S.-Y. Chang and R. Fefferman. This article presents several different variants of the Lemma, some known, some implicit in the literature, and…

Classical Analysis and ODEs · Mathematics 2007-05-23 Carlos Cabrelli , Michael Lacey , Ursula Molter , Jill C Pipher

Ogburn et al. (2019, arXiv:1910.05438) discuss "The Blessings of Multiple Causes" (Wang and Blei, 2018, arXiv:1805.06826). Many of their remarks are interesting. But they also claim that the paper has "foundational errors" and that its…

Machine Learning · Statistics 2019-12-24 Yixin Wang , David M. Blei

Different theoretical and experimental aspects of electromagnetic phenomena in media is reviewed. The 100 year old Minkowski theory is in agreement with most experiments, but has theoretical problems related to its implied validity in all…

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology · Physics 2008-10-13 Finn Ravndal

We refute criticisms by Del Santo and Horvat towards our paper "Quantum principle of relativity": most of their counterarguments can be dismissed, and the rest provides further evidence to our claims.

Quantum Physics · Physics 2022-10-19 Andrzej Dragan , Artur Ekert

In a recent article, Khrennikov claims that a particular theorem about agreement between quantum measurement results poses a problem for the interpretation of quantum mechanics known as QBism. Considering the basic setup of that theorem in…

Quantum Physics · Physics 2023-02-21 Blake C. Stacey