The Critical Mass in Galaxy Evolution

We investigate the physical origin of critical mass, a threshold where many galaxy properties and scaling relations undergo fundamental transitions, using the Horizon Run 5 simulation. Focusing on massive ($M_{\rm tot} \geq 10^{12}{\rm M_\odot}$) central galaxies, we examine the mass-dependent turnover of the stellar-to-total mass ratio (STR) and the physical processes driving it. We decompose STR into the stellar-to-baryon mass ratio ($M_*/M_{\rm bar}$) and baryon retention fraction ($M_{\rm bar}/M_{\rm tot}$) to examine galaxies' ability to retain baryons and convert them into stars. We find that STR evolution is dominated by variation in $M_*/M_{\rm bar}$, which changes by over a factor of three, peaking within a narrow range of $M_{\rm tot} \sim 10^{12.4\text{--}12.7}{\rm M_\odot}$ independent of redshift, while $M_{\rm bar}/M_{\rm tot}$ varies by at most 30%. A redshift-independent critical mass at $M_{\rm tot} \sim 10^{12.5}{\rm M_\odot}$ ($M_* \sim 10^{10.7}{\rm M_\odot}$) arises from the changing nature of gas accretion. At this scale, a dynamically stable hot gas halo develops that suppresses cool gas inflow, reducing in-situ star formation efficiency such that $M_{\rm tot}$ growth exceeds in-situ $M_{*}$ growth. Consequently, the hot gas reservoir grows while $M_{*}$ growth slows, producing upturns in $M_{\rm gas}/M_{\rm tot}$ and $M_{\rm bar}/M_{\rm tot}$ and a downturn in $M_{*}/M_{\rm bar}$ that ultimately drives the STR turnover. We also identify a secondary critical mass at $M_{\rm tot} \approx 10^{11}{\rm M_\odot}$ (or $M_{*} \approx 10^{9\text{--}9.5}{\rm M_\odot}$) where gas retention fraction peaks, above which increasing hot gas fraction gradually suppresses in-situ star formation efficiency.