The Challenging History of Other Earths
Abstract
This paper provides an overview of recent historical research regarding scientifically-informed challenges to the idea that the stars are other suns orbited by other inhabited earths -- an idea that came to be known as "the Plurality of Worlds". Johannes Kepler in the seventeenth century, Jacques Cassini in the eighteenth, and William Whewell in the nineteenth each argued against "pluralism" based on what in their respective times was solid science. Nevertheless, pluralism remained popular despite these and other scientific challenges. This history will be of interest to the astronomical community so that it is better positioned to avoid difficulties should the historical trajectory of pluralism continue, especially as it persists in the popular imagination.
Keywords
Cite
@article{arxiv.2409.11349,
title = {The Challenging History of Other Earths},
author = {Christopher M. Graney},
journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2409.11349},
year = {2024}
}
Comments
17 pages, 6 figures. Posted to arXiv 6+ months after publication, in accordance with Cambridge University Press & Assessment "Licence to Publish" regarding "accepted manuscript"