English

The Bounce Has No Direction: Sign, Magnitude, and the Microstructure of Equity Return Predictability

Trading and Market Microstructure 2026-06-28 v1

Abstract

SPY's lag-1 return autocorrelation (ρ^(1)=0.081\hat\rho(1)=-0.081, z=7.4z=-7.4) is among the most significant regularities in empirical equity finance, yet the standard variance-ratio (VR) test cannot determine whether it reflects directional reversal or magnitude shrinkage - phenomena with entirely different trading implications. We develop the Fourier-Residue Identity (FRI), which decomposes return autocorrelation into a sign (k=2k=2) and a magnitude (k=4k=4) channel, each independently testable and neither redundant. Applied to six US instruments over 1993--2026 and a 21-instrument cross-asset panel, the FRI delivers a sharp microstructure diagnosis. The lag-1 autocorrelation in SPY is driven entirely by magnitude: the FRI sign test is insignificant (p=0.11p=0.11) while the full test achieves p<1012p<10^{-12}. A large move yesterday predicts a smaller move today regardless of direction - the fingerprint of bid-ask bounce and non-synchronous constituent staleness, not directional reversal. At lag 3, a significant directional reversal (p=0.02p=0.02) invisible to the scalar ACF reveals a separate partial-price-adjustment channel. We prove the Fejer identity VR(q)=1+2C_q (confirmed to <0.001 on all series), giving the Lo-MacKinlay test a spectral interpretation, and introduce a subsample diagnostic R_N=G_{N/2}/G_N that classifies equity autocorrelation as structural (R_N->1) rather than sampling noise (R_N->sqrt(2)). The cross-asset panel shows mean reversion confined to exchange-traded equities and sovereign bonds; credit ETFs, commodities, FX, and crypto are indistinguishable from random walks. All estimators pass 27 unit tests; Monte Carlo confirms correct 5% size under GARCH.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2606.29591,
  title  = {The Bounce Has No Direction: Sign, Magnitude, and the Microstructure of Equity Return Predictability},
  author = {Victoria Portnaya},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2606.29591},
  year   = {2026}
}

Comments

29 pages, 8 tables, no figures