Synthesis of passive multidimensional scattering matrices: a survey

The goal of this exposition is twofold. First, it surveys the current status of the synthesis of rational multivariable ($n$-dimensional) passive linear shift-invariant bounded-real (or positive-real) transfer functions as scattering (or immittance) matrices of networks composed of a finite number of $n$ types of inductive and capacitive elements together with memoryless reciprocal and nonreciprocal components, such as transformers and gyrators. The theory seeks to extend the classical $1$-D network synthesis framework to the multidimensional ($n$-D) setting. Second, the exposition examines the fundamental connection between $n$-D network synthesis and Hilbert's 17th problem concerning the representation of positive polynomials as sums of squares. This connection is shown to be the principal mathematical obstacle to extending many classical synthesis results to higher dimensions. Both lossless and dissipative transfer functions are considered. While every $2$-D lossless transfer function can be synthesized, the classical procedure of embedding a dissipative transfer function into a lossless one by solving an associated matrix dilation problem can be executed via spectral factorization only partially in $2$-D and fails in general for $n>2$. Moreover, for $n>2$, even lossless transfer functions are not, in general, synthesizable, except for certain low-degree stable all-pass functions. These limitations ultimately stem from Hilbert's 17th problem referred to above. The exposition also reviews failure of several other classical $1$-D synthesis techniques, including matrix-factorization methods, thereby providing a comprehensive account of the current state of $n$-D network synthesis. Depending on the context, both continuous and discrete time formulations are employed; for the class of linear shift-invariant systems considered here, this change of setting entails no loss of generality.