English

Sets with dependent elements: A formalization of Castoriadis' notion of magma

Logic 2026-03-12 v2

Abstract

We present a formalization of collections that Cornelius Castoriadis calls ``magmas'', especially the property which mainly characterizes them and distinguishes them from the usual cantorian sets. It is the property of their elements to {\em depend} on other elements, either in a one-way or a two-way manner, so that one cannot occur in a collection without the occurrence of those dependent on it. Such a dependence relation can be represented by a pre-order relation \preccurlyeq Then, working in a mild strengthening of the theory ZFA{\rm ZFA}, where AA is an infinite set of atoms equipped with a primitive pre-ordering \preccurlyeq, the class of magmas over AA is represented by the class LO(A,)LO(A,\preccurlyeq) of nonempty open subsets of AA with respect to the lower topology of A,\langle A,\preccurlyeq\rangle. Next the pre-ordering \preccurlyeq is shifted (by a kind of simulation) to a pre-ordering +\preccurlyeq^+ on P(A){\cal P}(A), which turns out to satisfy the same non-minimality condition as well, and which, happily, when restricted to LO(A,)LO(A,\preccurlyeq) coincides with \subseteq. This allows us to define a hierarchy Mα(A)M_\alpha(A), along all ordinals α1\alpha\geq 1, the``magmatic hierarchy'', such that M1(A)=LO(A,)M_1(A)=LO(A,\preccurlyeq), Mα+1(A)=LO(Mα(A),)M_{\alpha+1}(A)=LO(M_\alpha(A),\subseteq), and Mα(A)=β<αMβ(A)M_\alpha(A)=\bigcup_{\beta<\alpha}M_\beta(A), for a limit ordinal α\alpha. For every α1\alpha\geq 1, Mα(A)Vα(A)M_\alpha(A)\subseteq V_\alpha(A), where Vα(A)V_\alpha(A) are the levels of the universe V(A)V(A) of ZFA{\rm ZFA}. The class M(A)=α1Mα(A)M(A)=\bigcup_{\alpha\geq 1}M_\alpha(A) is the ``magmatic universe above AA.''

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2303.09146,
  title  = {Sets with dependent elements: A formalization of Castoriadis' notion of magma},
  author = {Athanassios Tzouvaras},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2303.09146},
  year   = {2026}
}

Comments

24 pages