English

Reply to "Comment on `Validity of path thermodynamic description of reactive systems: Microscopic simulations'

Statistical Mechanics 2023-09-12 v1 Chemical Physics

Abstract

The Comment's author argues that a correct description of reactive systems should incorporate the explicit interaction with reservoirs, leading to a unified system-reservoirs entity. However, this proposition has two major flaws. Firstly, as we will emphasize, this entity inherently follows a thermodynamic equilibrium distribution. In the Comment, no indication is provided on how to maintain such a system-reservoirs entity in a non-equilibrium state. Secondly, contrary to the author's claim, the inclusion of system-reservoir interaction in traditional stochastic modeling of reactive systems does not automatically alter the limited applicability of path thermodynamics to problematic reactive systems. We will provide a simple demonstration to illustrate that certain elementary reactions may not involve any changes in reservoir components, which seems to have been overlooked by the author.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2309.05485,
  title  = {Reply to "Comment on `Validity of path thermodynamic description of reactive systems: Microscopic simulations'},
  author = {F. Baras and A. L. Garcia and M. Malek Mansour},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2309.05485},
  year   = {2023}
}

Comments

To appear in Physical Review E