Quasi-Newton and Krylov Methods for the Solution of Nonconvex Trust-Region Subproblems

We study the solution of symmetric positive-definite linear systems by way of families of full- and limited-memory methods. Our contributions are threefold. We first derive new relationships between the conjugate-gradient method (CG) and quasi-Newton methods of the Broyden class that refine existing results, and clarify when those methods generate the same iterates and enjoy quadratic termination. We extend this perspective to the limited-memory BFGS (LBFGS) method. Next, we examine how DIOM, a limited-memory variant of the full orthogonalization Krylov method (FOM), is akin to LBFGS in that it provides a memory lever that is critical in practical performance. Finally, we generalize LBFGS and DIOM to the computation of trust-region steps for unconstrained, potentially nonconvex, optimization. We report numerical experience on positive-definite linear systems and unconstrained optimization problems. The results show that memory is a key algorithmic lever: LBFGS and DIOM are consistently more robust than CG and often achieve comparable accuracy with fewer Hessian-vector products. They emerge as viable alternatives to CG when high accuracy is desirable or when operations with the Hessian are at a premium. The limited-memory SR1 (LSR1) method can be competitive in full-memory form, but its limited-memory variant suffers from discarded curvature information.