To observe Majorana bound states, and especially to use them as a qubit, requires careful optimization of competing quality metrics. We systematically compare Majorana quality in proximitized semiconductor nanowires and quantum dot chains. Using multi-objective optimization, we analyze the fundamental trade-offs between topological gap and localization length, two key metrics that determine MBS coherence and operational fidelity. We demonstrate that these quantities cannot be simultaneously optimized in realistic models, creating Pareto frontiers that define the achievable parameter space. Our results show that QD chains achieve both comparable quality as nanowires and a regime with a much shorter localization length, making them particularly promising for near-term quantum computing applications where device length and disorder are limiting factors.
@article{arxiv.2510.07406,
title = {Pareto-optimality of Majoranas in hybrid platforms},
author = {Juan Daniel Torres Luna and Sebastian Miles and A. Mert Bozkurt and Chun-Xiao Liu and Antonio L. R. Manesco and Anton R. Akhmerov and Michael Wimmer},
journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2510.07406},
year = {2025}
}