English

On the distinct maximal-clique sizes in $3$-uniform hypergraphs

Combinatorics 2026-07-30 v1

Abstract

Let g(n,k)g(n,k) be the largest possible number of distinct sizes of maximal cliques in a kk-uniform hypergraph on nn vertices, and let f(n,k)=ng(n,k)f(n,k)=n-g(n,k). In the graph case, Spencer proved in 1971 that f(n,2)=Θ(logn)f(n,2)=\Theta(\log n). For 33-uniform hypergraphs, Erd\H{o}s constructed examples showing that f(n,3)logn+O(1)f(n,3)\le \log^* n+O(1), where logn\log^* n is the number of iterated logarithms such that logloglogn<1\log\log \ldots \log n<1. Recently, Gao (JCT-B, 2026) proved that f(n,3)loglognO(1)f(n,3)\ge\log \log^* n-O(1), thereby answering a question posed by Erd\H{o}s. In the same paper, Gao defined the associated layered-tree threshold c(n,3)c(n,3) and asked whether f(n,k)=Θ(c(n,3))f(n,k)=\Theta(c(n,3)). In this paper, we determine the correct order f(n,3)=Θ(logn).f(n,3)=\Theta(\log^* n). Since c(n,3)=loglogn+O(1)c(n,3)=\log\log^* n+O(1), our result gives a negative answer to Gao's question in the case k=3k=3. We conclude by proposing the following conjecture: f(n,k)=Θk ⁣(2c(n,k))f(n,k)=\Theta_k\!\left(2^{c(n,k)}\right) for every fixed k3k\ge3.

Cite

@article{arxiv.2607.27837,
  title  = {On the distinct maximal-clique sizes in $3$-uniform hypergraphs},
  author = {Jiabao Yang and Leilei Zhang},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2607.27837},
  year   = {2026}
}

Comments

10 pages, no figures; comments welcome