English

On automorphisms groups of structures of countable cofinality

Logic 2015-06-09 v3 General Topology

Abstract

In [2] Su Gao proves that the following are equivalent for a countable MM (cf. theorem 1.2 too): (I)There is an uncountable model of the Scott sentence of MM. (II) There exists some jAut(M)Aut(M)j\in \overline{Aut(M)}\setminus Aut(M), where Aut(M)\overline{Aut(M)} is the closure of Aut(M)Aut(M) under the product topology in ωω\omega^\omega. (III) There is an Lω1,ωL_{\omega_1,\omega}- elementary embedding jj from MM to itself such that range(j)Mrange(j)\subset M. We generalize his theorem to all cardinals κ\kappa of of cofinality ω\omega (cf. theorem 4.2). The following are equivalent: (I^*) There is a model of the Scott sentence of MM of size κ+\kappa^+. (II^*) For all α<β<κ+\alpha<\beta<\kappa^+, there exist functions jβ,αj_{\beta,\alpha} in Aut(M)TAut(M)\overline{Aut(M)}^{T}\setminus Aut(M), such that for α<β<γ<κ+\alpha< \beta<\gamma<\kappa^+, \begin{equation}(*) j_{\gamma,\beta}\circ j_{\beta,\alpha}=j_{\gamma,\alpha},\end{equation} where Aut(M)T\overline{Aut(M)}^{T} is the closure of Aut(M)Aut(M) under the product topology in κκ\kappa^\kappa. (III^*) For every β<κ+\beta<\kappa^+, there exist L,κfinL_{\infty,\kappa}^{fin}- elementary embeddings (cf. definition 2.5) (jα)α<β(j_\alpha)_{\alpha<\beta} from MM to itself such that α1<α2range(jα1)range(jα2)\alpha_1<\alpha_2\Rightarrow range(j_{\alpha_1})\subset range(j_{\alpha_2}). Theorem 4.2 holds both for countable and uncountable κ\kappa. Condition (*) in (II^*), which does not appear in the countable case, can not be removed when κ\kappa is uncountable (cf. theorem 4.5). Condition (II^*) imply the existence of at least κω\kappa^\omega automorphisms of MM (cf. corollary 4.6). It is unknown to the author whether a purely topological proof of corollary 4.6 exists.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.1211.7145,
  title  = {On automorphisms groups of structures of countable cofinality},
  author = {Ioannis Souldatos},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1211.7145},
  year   = {2015}
}

Comments

Paper is withdrawn for now. There is a problem with Lemma 3.3. If problem is resolved, a new version will be posted

R2 v1 2026-06-21T22:46:35.403Z