English

Non-Gaussian Error Distribution of $\rm{^{7}Li}$ Abundance Measurements

Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics 2015-07-22 v2

Abstract

We construct the error distribution of 7Li\rm{^{7}Li} abundance measurements for 66 observations (with error bars) used by Spite12 that give A(Li)=2.21±0.065\rm{A(Li)}=2.21 \pm 0.065 (median and 1σ\sigma symmetrized error). This error distribution is somewhat non-Gaussian, with larger probability in the tails than is predicted by a Gaussian distribution. The 95.4% confidence limits are 3.0σ\sigma in terms of the quoted errors. We fit the data to four commonly used distributions: Gaussian, Cauchy, Student's t, and double exponential with the center of the distribution found with both weighted mean and median statistics. It is reasonably well described by a widened n=8n=8 Student's tt distribution. Assuming Gaussianity, the observed A(Li) is 6.5σ\sigma away from that expected from standard Big Bang nucleosynthesis given the PlanckPlanck observations Coc2014. Accounting for the non-Gaussianity of the observed A(Li) error distribution reduces the discrepancy to 4.9σ\sigma, which is still significant.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.1409.7332,
  title  = {Non-Gaussian Error Distribution of $\rm{^{7}Li}$ Abundance Measurements},
  author = {Sara Crandall and Stephen Houston and Bharat Ratra},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1409.7332},
  year   = {2015}
}

Comments

24 pages, 6 figures, 4 tables