Neutrino oscillations: Quantum mechanics vs. quantum field theory
Abstract
A consistent description of neutrino oscillations requires either the quantum-mechanical (QM) wave packet approach or a quantum field theoretic (QFT) treatment. We compare these two approaches to neutrino oscillations and discuss the correspondence between them. In particular, we derive expressions for the QM neutrino wave packets from QFT and relate the free parameters of the QM framework, in particular the effective momentum uncertainty of the neutrino state, to the more fundamental parameters of the QFT approach. We include in our discussion the possibilities that some of the neutrino's interaction partners are not detected, that the neutrino is produced in the decay of an unstable parent particle, and that the overlap of the wave packets of the particles involved in the neutrino production (or detection) process is not maximal. Finally, we demonstrate how the properly normalized oscillation probabilities can be obtained in the QFT framework without an ad hoc normalization procedure employed in the QM approach.
Keywords
Cite
@article{arxiv.1001.4815,
title = {Neutrino oscillations: Quantum mechanics vs. quantum field theory},
author = {Evgeny Kh. Akhmedov and Joachim Kopp},
journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1001.4815},
year = {2012}
}
Comments
LaTeX, 42 pages, 1 figure; v2: minor clarifications, matches published version; v3: Corrected the discussion of the conditions under which an oscillation probability can be sensibly defined in the QFT approach (sec. 5.2.4)