English

Measuring The Impact Of Programming Language Distribution

Machine Learning 2023-05-25 v3 Computation and Language Programming Languages

Abstract

Current benchmarks for evaluating neural code models focus on only a small subset of programming languages, excluding many popular languages such as Go or Rust. To ameliorate this issue, we present the BabelCode framework for execution-based evaluation of any benchmark in any language. BabelCode enables new investigations into the qualitative performance of models' memory, runtime, and individual test case results. Additionally, we present a new code translation dataset called Translating Python Programming Puzzles (TP3) from the Python Programming Puzzles (Schuster et al. 2021) benchmark that involves translating expert-level python functions to any language. With both BabelCode and the TP3 benchmark, we investigate if balancing the distributions of 14 languages in a training dataset improves a large language model's performance on low-resource languages. Training a model on a balanced corpus results in, on average, 12.34% higher pass@kpass@k across all tasks and languages compared to the baseline. We find that this strategy achieves 66.48% better pass@kpass@k on low-resource languages at the cost of only a 12.94% decrease to high-resource languages. In our three translation tasks, this strategy yields, on average, 30.77% better low-resource pass@kpass@k while having 19.58% worse high-resource pass@kpass@k.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2302.01973,
  title  = {Measuring The Impact Of Programming Language Distribution},
  author = {Gabriel Orlanski and Kefan Xiao and Xavier Garcia and Jeffrey Hui and Joshua Howland and Jonathan Malmaud and Jacob Austin and Rishabh Singh and Michele Catasta},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2302.01973},
  year   = {2023}
}

Comments

Accepted to ICML 2023, Code and data release: https://github.com/google-research/babelcode

R2 v1 2026-06-28T08:31:42.699Z