English

Linear-wave bound on electromagnetic energy equipartition at sub-electron scales in non-relativistic plasmas

Plasma Physics 2026-04-21 v1

Abstract

Recent Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) observations report approximate equality between electric and magnetic field energy spectral densities, ε0P[δE]/2P[δB]/(2μ0)\varepsilon_{0} P[\delta E]/2 \approx P[\delta B]/(2\mu_{0}), at sub-electron scales in reconnection-driven magnetotail turbulence, interpreted as relaxation toward thermodynamic equilibrium. We derive the electric-to-magnetic energy ratio from the linear polarization of kinetic Alfv\'en waves and whistler-mode waves in the two-fluid framework and show that it saturates at R=(VA/c)2(mi/me)(βe/2)\mathcal{R}_{\infty}=(V_{A}/c)^{2}(m_{i}/m_{e})(\beta_{e}/2) deep in the sub-electron regime. Setting R=1\mathcal{R}_{\infty}=1 yields the universal threshold VA/c2/[(mi/me)βe]V_{A}/c \gtrsim \sqrt{2/[(m_{i}/m_{e})\beta_{e}]}, which no non-relativistic space plasma satisfies. For typical magnetotail parameters, R2×103\mathcal{R}_{\infty}\approx 2\times 10^{-3}, approximately 500 times below the observed value, a discrepancy rooted in the non-relativistic ordering (VA/c)21(V_{A}/c)^{2}\ll 1. Noise-floor estimates show that Search Coil Magnetometer and Electric Double Probe sensitivity convergence produces a spurious apparent equipartition throughout this regime. The observed equality likely reflects nonlinear dynamics, incoherent superposition of electromagnetic and electrostatic fluctuations, or instrumental noise contamination.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2604.18472,
  title  = {Linear-wave bound on electromagnetic energy equipartition at sub-electron scales in non-relativistic plasmas},
  author = {Vivek Shrivastav and Mani K Chettri and Britan Singh and Hemam D. Singh and Rupak Mukherjee},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2604.18472},
  year   = {2026}
}