English

Left-Separating Order Types

General Topology 2018-06-13 v2 Logic

Abstract

A well ordering < of a topological space X is "left-separating" if {xX:x<x}\{x'\in X: x'< x\} is closed in X for any x in X. A space is "left-separated" if it has a left-separating well-ordering. The left-separating type, ordl(X)ord_l(X), of a left-separated space X is the minimum of the order types of the left-separating well orderings of X. We prove that (1) if κ{\kappa} is a regular cardinal, then for each ordinal α<κ+{\alpha}<{\kappa}^+ there is a T2T_2 space XX with ordl(X)=καord_l(X)={\kappa}\cdot {\alpha}; (2) if κ=λ+{\kappa}={\lambda}^+ and cf(λ)=λ>ωcf({\lambda})={\lambda}>{\omega}, then for each ordinal α<κ+{\alpha}<{\kappa}^+ there is a 0-dimensional space XX with ordl(X)=καord_l( X)={\kappa}\cdot {\alpha}; (3) if κ=2ω{\kappa}=2^{\omega} or κ=β+1{\kappa}=\beth_{{\beta}+1}, where cf(β)=ωcf({\beta})={\omega}, then for each ordinal α<κ+{\alpha}<{\kappa}^+ there is a locally compact, locally countable, 0-dimensional space XX with ordl(X)=καord_l( X)={\kappa}\cdot {\alpha}. The union of two left-separated spaces is not necessarily left-separated. We show, however, that if X is a countably tight space, X=YZ,ordl(Y)X=Y\cup Z, ord_l(Y), ordl(Z)<ω1ωord_l(Z)<\omega_1 \cdot \omega, then XX is also left-separated and ordl(X)ordl(Y)+ordl(Z)ord_l(X)\le ord_l(Y)+ord_l(Z). We prove that it is consistent that there is a first countable, 0-dimensional space X, which is not left-separated, but there is a c.c.c poset Q such that in the generic extension VQV^Q we have ordl(X)=ω1ωord_l(X)=\omega_1 \cdot \omega. However, if XX is a topological space and QQ is a c.c.c poset such that in in the generic extension VQV^Q we have ordl(X)<ω1ωord_l(X)<\omega_1 \cdot \omega then X is left-separated even in VV.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.1609.09695,
  title  = {Left-Separating Order Types},
  author = {Lajos Soukup and Adrienne Stanley},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1609.09695},
  year   = {2018}
}

Comments

revised version with some new results, 23 pages

R2 v1 2026-06-22T16:06:32.810Z