English

Landscaping Systematic Mapping Studies in Software Engineering: A Tertiary Study

Software Engineering 2019-09-25 v1

Abstract

Context: A number of Systematic Mapping Studies (SMSs) that cover Software Engineering (SE) are reported in literature. Tertiary studies synthesize the secondary studies to provide a holistic view of an area. Objectives: We synthesize SMSs in SE to provide insights into existing SE areas and to investigate the trends and quality of SMSs. Methodology: We use Systematic Literature Review protocol to analyze and map the SMSs in SE, till August 2017, to SE Body of Knowledge (SWEBOK). Results: We analyze 210 SMSs and results show that: (1) Software design and construction are most active areas in SE; (2) Some areas lack SMSs, including mathematical foundations, software configuration management, and SE tools; (3) The quality of SMSs is improving with time; (4) SMSs in journals have higher quality than SMSs in conferences and are cited more often; (5) Low quality in SMSs can be attributed to a lack of quality assessment in SMSs and not reporting information about the primary studies. Conclusion: There is a potential for more SMSs in some SE areas. A number of SMSs do not provide the required information for an SMS, which leads to a low quality score.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.1909.10751,
  title  = {Landscaping Systematic Mapping Studies in Software Engineering: A Tertiary Study},
  author = {Muhammad Uzair khan and Salman Sherin and Muhammad Zohaib Iqbal and Rubab Zahid},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1909.10751},
  year   = {2019}
}
R2 v1 2026-06-23T11:23:58.842Z