English

III. Interacting Dark Energy: Summary of Models, Pathologies, and Constraints

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology 2025-10-20 v3 Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics

Abstract

We present an overview of the main results from our two companion papers that are relevant for observational constraints on interacting dark energy (IDE) models. We provide analytical solutions for the dark matter and dark energy densities, ρdm\rho_{\rm dm} and ρde\rho_{\rm de}, as well as the normalized Hubble function h(z)h(z), for eight IDE models. These include five linear IDE models, namely Q=3H(δdmρdm+δdeρde)Q=3H(\delta_{\rm dm} \rho_{\rm dm} + \delta_{\rm de} \rho_{\rm de}) and four special cases: Q=3Hδ(ρdm+ρde)Q=3H\delta(\rho_{\rm dm}+\rho_{\rm de}), Q=3Hδ(ρdmρde)Q=3H\delta(\rho_{\rm dm}-\rho_{\rm de}), Q=3HδρdmQ=3H\delta \rho_{\rm dm}, and Q=3HδρdeQ=3H\delta \rho_{\rm de}, together with three non-linear IDE models: Q=3Hδ(ρdmρdeρdm+ρde)Q=3H\delta \left( \tfrac{\rho_{\rm dm} \rho_{\rm de}}{\rho_{\rm dm}+\rho_{\rm de}} \right), Q=3Hδ(ρdm2ρdm+ρde)Q=3H\delta \left( \tfrac{\rho_{\rm dm}^2}{\rho_{\rm dm}+\rho_{\rm de}} \right), and Q=3Hδ(ρde2ρdm+ρde)Q=3H\delta \left( \tfrac{\rho_{\rm de}^2}{\rho_{\rm dm}+\rho_{\rm de}} \right). For these eight models, we present conditions to avoid imaginary, undefined, and negative energy densities. In seven of the eight cases, negative densities arise if energy flows from DM to DE, implying a strong theoretical preference for energy transfer from DE to DM. We also provide conditions to avoid future big rip singularities and evaluate how each model addresses the coincidence problem in both the past and the future. Finally, we propose a set of approaches and simplifying assumptions that can be used when constraining IDE models, by defining regimes that restrict the parameter space according to the behavior researchers are willing to tolerate.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2509.04496,
  title  = {III. Interacting Dark Energy: Summary of Models, Pathologies, and Constraints},
  author = {Marcel van der Westhuizen and Amare Abebe and Eleonora Di Valentino},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2509.04496},
  year   = {2025}
}

Comments

17 pages, 1 figure, 4 tables. This work is the third in a series of three companion papers on interacting dark energy: I. Linear Interacting Dark Energy (arXiv:2509.04495), II. Non-Linear Interacting Dark Energy (arXiv:2509.04494), and III. Summary and Constraints