English

Hidden Complex Structure in Quotient-Space Real Quantum Mechanics

Quantum Physics 2026-07-07 v1

Abstract

Barrios Hita et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 136\bf{136}, 240202 (2026)] argued that quantum mechanics can be formulated over the real numbers by replacing the tensor-product postulate with a quotient-space construction, and concluded that complex numbers are therefore a matter of convenience. We show that the operational content of this construction is not that of a generic real Hilbert-space theory. Empirical equivalence requires a distinguished real linear operator JJ with J2=1J^2 = -\mathbb{1}, and all physical effects, instruments, and dynamics must preserve the corresponding SO(2)SO(2) gauge. Moreover, the composite-system rule is a balanced tensor product over this hidden complex structure, not the ordinary tensor product over R\mathbb{R}. In multipartite network scenarios, this changes the meaning of source independence: canonical real representatives are not source-factorizable in the usual tensor-product sense. Thus, the construction is best understood as standard complex quantum mechanics written in real notation, not as an independent real-amplitude theory. This clarifies what is, and is not, excluded by experiments testing the necessity of complex numbers.

Cite

@article{arxiv.2607.05865,
  title  = {Hidden Complex Structure in Quotient-Space Real Quantum Mechanics},
  author = {Jeongho Bang and Kyoungho Cho and Kyunghyun Baek},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2607.05865},
  year   = {2026}
}

Comments

17 pages (main text + supplemental material)