Scanning SQUID is a local magnetometer which can image flux through its pickup loop due to DC magnetic fields (Φ). Scanning SQUID can also measure a sample's magnetic response to an applied current (dΦ/dI) or voltage (dΦ/dV) using standard lock-in techniques. In this manuscript, we demonstrate that electric coupling between the scanning SQUID and a back gate-tuned, magnetic sample can lead to a gate-voltage dependent artifact when imaging dΦ/dI or dΦ/dV. The electric coupling artifact results in dΦ/dV and dΦ/dI images which mimic the spatial variation of the static magnetic fields from the sample (e.g. ferromagnetic domains). In back-gated EuS/Bi2Se3 bilayers, we show that the electric coupling effect is important, and is responsible for the reported signal from chiral currents in Y.H. Wang, et al. (DOI: 10.1126/science.aaa0508). Previous scanning SQUID current imaging experiments are unaffected by this artifact, as they are either on non-magnetic samples or the spatial distribution of magnetism does not match the features observed in dΦ/dI. In conclusion, dΦ/dI or dΦ/dV imaging of magnetic, back-gated samples should only be applied and interpreted with great caution.
@article{arxiv.1512.03373,
title = {Electric coupling in scanning SQUID measurements},
author = {Eric M. Spanton and Aaron J. Rosenberg and Yihua H. Wang and John R. Kirtley and Ferhat Katmis and Pablo Jarillo-Herrero and Jagadeesh S. Moodera and Kathryn A. Moler},
journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1512.03373},
year = {2015}
}
Comments
This is a comment on Y.H. Wang, et al. (DOI: 10.1126/science.aaa0508), which has been retracted (DOI: 10.1126/science.350.6267.1482-a)