English

Effective powers of $\omega$ over $\Delta_2$ cohesive sets and infinite $\Pi_1$ sets without $\Delta_2$ cohesive subsets

Logic 2023-10-11 v2

Abstract

A cohesive power of a computable structure is an effective ultrapower where a cohesive set acts as an ultrafilter. Let ω\omega, ζ\zeta, and η\eta denote the respective order-types of the natural numbers, the integers, and the rationals. We study cohesive powers of computable copies of ω\omega over Δ2\Delta_2 cohesive sets. We show that there is a computable copy L\mathcal{L} of ω\omega such that, for every Δ2\Delta_2 cohesive set CC, the cohesive power of L\mathcal{L} over CC has order-type ω+η\omega + \eta. This improves an earlier result of Dimitrov, Harizanov, Morozov, Shafer, A. Soskova, and Vatev by generalizing from Σ1\Sigma_1 cohesive sets to Δ2\Delta_2 cohesive sets and by computing a single copy of ω\omega that has the desired cohesive power over all Δ2\Delta_2 cohesive sets. Furthermore, our result is optimal in the sense that Δ2\Delta_2 cannot be replaced by Π2\Pi_2. More generally, we show that if XN{0}X \subseteq \mathbb{N} \setminus \{0\} is a Boolean combination of Σ2\Sigma_2 sets, thought of as a set of finite order-types, then there is a computable copy L\mathcal{L} of ω\omega where the cohesive power of L\mathcal{L} over any Δ2\Delta_2 cohesive set has order-type ω+σ(X{ω+ζη+ω})\omega + \sigma(X \cup \{\omega + \zeta\eta + \omega^*\}). If XX is finite and non-empty, then there is also a computable copy L\mathcal{L} of ω\omega where the cohesive power of L\mathcal{L} over any Δ2\Delta_2 cohesive set has order-type ω+σ(X)\omega + \sigma(X). An unexpected byproduct of our work is a new method for constructing infinite Π1\Pi_1 sets that do not have Δ2\Delta_2 cohesive subsets. In fact, we construct an infinite Π1\Pi_1 set that does not have a Δ2\Delta_2 p-cohesive subset. Infinite Π1\Pi_1 sets without Δ2\Delta_2 r-cohesive subsets generalize D. Martin's classic co-infinite c.e. set with no maximal superset and have appeared in the work of Lerman, Shore, and Soare.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2202.04998,
  title  = {Effective powers of $\omega$ over $\Delta_2$ cohesive sets and infinite $\Pi_1$ sets without $\Delta_2$ cohesive subsets},
  author = {Paul Shafer},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2202.04998},
  year   = {2023}
}

Comments

arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2009.00340