Cryptanalysis of quantum permutation pad

Cryptanalysis increases the level of confidence in cryptographic algorithms. We analyze the security of a symmetric cryptographic algorithm - quantum permutation pad (QPP) [8]. We found the instances of ciphertext the same as plaintext even after the action of QPP with the probability 1/N when the entire set of permutation matrices of dimension N is used and with the probability 1/N^m when an incomplete set of m permutation matrices of dimension N are used. We visually show such instances in a cipher image created by QPP of 256 permutation matrices of different dimensions. For any practical usage of QPP, we recommend a set of 256 permutation matrices of a dimension more or equal to 2048.