English

Comment on "Thermal Hall Effect and Geometry with Torsion"

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology 2016-07-07 v2 Other Condensed Matter High Energy Physics - Theory
Authors: Rabin Banerjee , Pradip Mukherjee
View on arXiv ↗ PDF ↗

Abstract

This is a comment on a paper by Gromov and Abanov [Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 016802 (2015)]. We will show that there is an inconsistency which renders the results untenable.

Keywords

comment and reply

Cite

@article{arxiv.1512.05860,
  title  = {Comment on "Thermal Hall Effect and Geometry with Torsion"},
  author = {Rabin Banerjee and Pradip Mukherjee},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1512.05860},
  year   = {2016}
}

Comments

LaTeX, 2 pages, expanded with new input

Related papers

View all related →
Materials Science · Physics
From Anomalous Hall Effect to the Quantum Anomalous Hall Effect
Hongming Weng, Xi Dai, Zhong Fang
2015-09-21
Materials Science · Physics
Comment on "Theory of Spin Hall Effect: Extension of the Drude Model"
V. Ya. Kravchenko
2008-05-27
Disordered Systems and Neural Networks · Physics
Comment on `Symmetrical Temperature-Chaos effect with Positive and Negative Temperature Shifts in a Spin Glass'
Ludovic Berthier, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud
2009-11-07
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics · Physics
Comment on Theory of spin Hall effect
J. E. Hirsch
2007-09-11
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology · Physics
Thermodynamics of unparticle-enhanced black holes
Yun Soo Myung
2010-10-22
Strongly Correlated Electrons · Physics
Anomalous Hall effect in heavy electron materials
Yi-feng Yang
2013-01-03
Superconductivity · Physics
Comment on Yerin et al , Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 077002 (2018), and, Mironov et al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 237002 (2012)
A. F. Volkov, F. S. Bergeret, K. B. Efetov
2018-10-12
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology · Physics
Comment on "Thermodynamic properties of Schwarzschild black hole in non-commutative gauge theory of gravity"
A. A. Araújo Filho, Iarley P. Lobo
2025-12-17
High Energy Physics - Phenomenology · Physics
Reply to Comment on "Acoustics of tachyon Fermi gas"
Ernst Trojan, George V. Vlasov
2015-06-18
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics · Physics
Thermal transport, geometry, and anomalies
Maxim N. Chernodub, Yago Ferreiros, Adolfo G. Grushin, Karl Landsteiner +1
2022-08-02
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics · Physics
Comment on "Weyl fermions and the anomalous Hall effect in metallic ferromagnets"
David Vanderbilt, Ivo Souza, F. D. M. Haldane
2014-07-25
Mathematical Physics · Physics
Aharonov-Bohm effect revisited
Gregory Eskin
2015-06-24
Classical Physics · Physics
Comment on the Letter "Geometric Origin of the Tennis Racket Effect'' by P. Mardesic, et al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 064301 (2020)
Alexei A. Deriglazov
2023-03-09
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology · Physics
Reply to the comment on "Black hole entropy and isolated horizons thermodynamics"
Amit Ghosh, Alejandro Perez
2012-04-20
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology · Physics
Comment to Comment to Black Hole in Dehnen $\left(1,4,\frac{1}{2}\right)$ Dark Matter Halo: Exact Solution, Lensing, Light Ring, and Thermodynamics
David Senjaya
2026-01-05
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics · Physics
Reply to the Comment by Tikhonov and Khrapai on "Long-range crossed Andreev reflection in a topological insulator nanowire proximitized by a superconductor"
Junya Feng, Henry F. Legg, Mahasweta Bagchi, Daniel Loss +2
2025-09-08
Quantum Physics · Physics
Comment on "On the temperature dependence of the Casimir effect"
V. B. Bezerra, R. S. Decca, E. Fischbach, B. Geyer +5
2016-08-16
Superconductivity · Physics
Comment on "Giant Nernst Effect due to Fluctuating Cooper Pairs in Superconductors" by M.N. Serbyn, M.A. Skvortsov, A.A. Varlamov, and V. Galitski
A. Sergeev, M. Y. Reizer, V. Mitin
2013-05-29
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics · Physics
Anomalous and Topological Hall Effects with Phase-Space Berry Curvatures: Electric, Thermal, and Thermoelectric Transport in Magnets
Zachariah Addison, Lauren Keyes, Mohit Randeria
2025-08-05
Superconductivity · Physics
Reply to "Comment on Yerin et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 077002 (2018), and Mironov et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 237002 (2012)" by A. F. Volkov, F. S. Bergeret, and K. B. Efetov
S. V. Mironov, D. Yu. Vodolazov, Y. Yerin, A. V. Samokhvalov +2
2018-12-10
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics · Physics
Torsion, energy magnetization and thermal Hall effect
Ze-Min Huang, Bo Han, Xiao-Qi Sun
2022-02-16
Strongly Correlated Electrons · Physics
Thermal Hall Effect and Geometry with Torsion
Andrey Gromov, Alexander G. Abanov
2015-02-16
Nuclear Theory · Physics
Comment to the paper D. V. Anchishkin and S. N. Yezhov "Thermalization in Heavy-ion Collisions"
K. A. Bugaev
2008-07-30
Quantum Physics · Physics
Comment on "Using an atom interferometer to infer gravitational entanglement generation''
Daniel Carney, Holger Muller, Jacob M. Taylor
2021-11-09
Disordered Systems and Neural Networks · Physics
Comments on Thermometer Effect -- Origin of the Mixed Alkali Effect in Glass Relaxation by Y.Yu et al. [Phys.Rev.Lett. 119, 095501 (2017)]
Vladimir Belostotsky
2021-01-05
R2 v1 2026-06-22T12:13:05.708Z