English

Comment on "A test-tube model for rainfall" by Wilkinson M., EPL 106 (2014) 40001

Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics 2014-11-11 v1 Soft Condensed Matter
Authors: Martin Rohloff , Tobias Lapp , Jürgen Vollmer
View on arXiv ↗ PDF ↗ DOI ↗

Abstract

This paper is a comment to M Wilkinson, EPL 106 (2014) 40001, arXiv:1401.4620 [physics.ao-ph,cond-mat.soft], which draws conclusion from our data that are at variance with our observations.

Keywords

comment rainfall model test-tube model data discrepancy observations

Cite

@article{arxiv.1408.1263,
  title  = {Comment on "A test-tube model for rainfall" by Wilkinson M., EPL 106 (2014) 40001},
  author = {Martin Rohloff and Tobias Lapp and Jürgen Vollmer},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1408.1263},
  year   = {2014}
}

Related papers

View all related →
Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics · Physics
Reply to Comment by M. Rohloff, T. Lapp and J. Vollmer
Michael Wilkinson
2014-10-28
Statistical Mechanics · Physics
Response to Comment [arXiv:1407.6854] on Palmer et al., Nature, 510, 385, 2014
Jeremy C. Palmer, Pablo G. Debenedetti, Roberto Car, Athanassios Z. Panagiotopoulos
2014-07-31
Probability · Mathematics
Statistical Analysis of Precipitation Events
V. Yu. Korolev, A. K. Gorshenin, S. K. Gulev, K. P. Belyaev +1
2018-06-28
Fluid Dynamics · Physics
Dyanmics of falling raindrops
Yashvir Tibrewal, Nishchal Dwivedi
2023-10-31
Applications · Statistics
Modeling rainfalls using a seasonal hidden markov model
Augustin Touron
2017-10-24
Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics · Physics
Analyzing the Impact of Meteorological Parameters on Rainfall Prediction
Muhammad Salman Pathan, Jiantao Wu, Yee Hui Lee, Jianzhuo Yan +1
2021-10-22
Statistical Mechanics · Physics
Comment on "Capturing correlations in chaotic diffusion by approximation methods"
Thomas Gilbert, David P. Sanders
2011-11-29
Statistical Mechanics · Physics
Comment on "Temperature dependent fluctuations in the two-dimensional XY model"
G. Palma
2007-05-23
Signal Processing · Electrical Eng. & Systems
Probabilistic Rainfall Estimation from Automotive Lidar
Robin Karlsson, David Robert Wong, Kazunari Kawabata, Simon Thompson +1
2022-04-26
Statistics Theory · Mathematics
On tail trend detection: modeling relative risk
Laurens de Haan, Albert Klein Tank, Cláudia Neves
2015-06-16
Applications · Statistics
Robust statistical modeling of monthly rainfall: The minimum density power divergence approach
Arnab Hazra, Abhik Ghosh
2024-03-05
Soft Condensed Matter · Physics
Comment on 'Transient response of a wetting film to mechanical and electrical perturbations'
Roumen Tsekov
2011-04-14
Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics · Physics
Waving in the rain
Luigi Cavaleri, Luciana Bertotti, Jean-Raymond Bidlot
2015-03-11
Soft Condensed Matter · Physics
Comment on "Mode-Coupling Theory as a Mean-Field Description of the Glass Transition"
Rolf Schilling, Bernhard Schmid
2011-01-31
Statistical Mechanics · Physics
Comment on "Entropy Production and Fluctuation Theorems for Active Matter"
L. Caprini, U. Marini Bettolo Marconi, A. Puglisi, A. Vulpiani
2018-10-17
Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics · Physics
Making It Rain: How Giving Me Telescope Time Can Reduce Drought
Michael B. Lund
2020-04-01
Superconductivity · Physics
Comment on "Vortex Liquid Crystal in Anisotropic Type II Superconductors"
Xiao Hu, Qing-Hu Chen
2016-08-31
Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics · Physics
Data-driven analysis of annual rain distributions
Yosef Ashkenazy, Naftali R. Smith
2024-05-24
Statistical Mechanics · Physics
Comment on "Model for Heat Conduction in Nanofluids"
Sorin Bastea
2007-05-23
Soft Condensed Matter · Physics
Reply to Comment on "Faceting and flattening of emulsion droplets: a mechanical model" by Haas et al
Ireth García-Aguilar, Ayelet Atkins, Piermarco Fonda, Eli Sloutskin +1
2021-07-01
Soft Condensed Matter · Physics
Comment on "Faceting and Flattening of Emulsion Droplets: A Mechanical Model"
Pierre A. Haas, Raymond E. Goldstein, Diana Cholakova, Nikolai Denkov +1
2021-06-30
High Energy Physics - Lattice · Physics
Reply to A. Patrascioiu's and E. Seiler's Comment on our paper "Percolation properties of the 2D Heisenberg model"
B. Alles, J. J. Alonso, C. Criado, M. Pepe
2009-10-31
Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics · Physics
Electrical Route to Realising Intensity Simulation of Heavy Rain Events in Tropics
Dipjyoti Mudiar, Anupam Hazra, S. D. Pawar, Rama Krishna Karumuri +4
2020-04-21
Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics · Physics
A Data-driven Approach to Detecting Precipitation from Meteorological Sensor Data
Shilpa Manandhar, Soumyabrata Dev, Yee Hui Lee, Yu Song Meng +1
2018-05-08
Methodology · Statistics
Stable sums to infer high return levels of multivariate rainfall time series
Gloria Buriticá, Philippe Naveau
2022-05-13