English

Colored Stallings graphs and Counterexamples to Stallings equalizer conjecture

Group Theory 2026-05-12 v2

Abstract

The famous Stallings equalizer conjecture has remained open for more than 40 years, which states that, for any free group FnF_n of rank n2n\ge 2, any free group FF, and any two monomorphisms g,h:FnF,g,h:F_n\to F, the equalizer \Eq(g,h)={wFng(w)=h(w)}\Eq(g,h)=\{w\in F_n\mid g(w)=h(w)\} satisfies \rk\Eq(g,h)n.\rk \Eq(g,h)\le n. The only known case is n=2n=2, due to A. D. Logan in 2022. By introducing the notion of colored Stallings graphs, we show that for every integer n2n\ge 2 there exist monomorphisms g,h:FnF2g,h:F_n\longrightarrow F_2 such that\rk\Eq(g,h)2n2.\rk\Eq(g,h)\ge 2n-2. This disproves Stallings equalizer conjecture for n3n\ge 3.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2604.24502,
  title  = {Colored Stallings graphs and Counterexamples to Stallings equalizer conjecture},
  author = {Jialin Lei and Teng Zhang},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2604.24502},
  year   = {2026}
}

Comments

v2, 15 pages, this is the submitted version; v1, 10 pages, all comments are welcome!

R2 v1 2026-07-01T12:37:18.698Z