English

Clifford Strategies in Interactive Protocols are Classically Simulatable

Quantum Physics 2025-09-04 v3 Computational Complexity Cryptography and Security

Abstract

MIP\text{MIP}^\ast is the class of languages decidable by an efficient classical verifier interacting with multiple quantum provers that share entangled qubits but cannot communicate. Notably, MIP\text{MIP}^\ast was proved to equal RE\text{RE}, the class of all recursively enumerable languages. We introduce the complexity class Clifford-MIP\text{Clifford-MIP}^\ast, which restricts quantum provers to Clifford operations and classical post-processing of measurement results, while still allowing shared entangled qubits in any quantum state. We show that any strategy in this model can be simulated by classical provers with shared random bits, and therefore admits a local hidden-variable description. Consequently, Clifford-MIP=MIP\text{Clifford-MIP}^\ast = \text{MIP}, a vastly smaller complexity class compared to RE\text{RE}. Moreover, we resolve an open question posed by Kalai et al. (STOC 2023), by showing that quantum advantage in any single-round non-local game requires at least two provers operating outside the Clifford-MIP\text{Clifford-MIP}^\ast computational model. This rules out a proposed approach for significantly improving the efficiency of quantum advantage tests that are based on compiling non-local games into single-prover interactive protocols.

Cite

@article{arxiv.2410.12030,
  title  = {Clifford Strategies in Interactive Protocols are Classically Simulatable},
  author = {Itay Shalit},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2410.12030},
  year   = {2025}
}

Comments

This version includes an extended introduction. Accepted to TCC 2025

R2 v1 2026-06-28T19:23:19.080Z