English

Can One Detect Whether a Wave Function Has Collapsed?

Quantum Physics 2014-05-19 v2

Abstract

Consider a quantum system prepared in state ψ\psi, a unit vector in a dd-dimensional Hilbert space. Let b1,...,bdb_1,...,b_d be an orthonormal basis and suppose that, with some probability 0<p<10<p<1, ψ\psi ``collapses,'' i.e., gets replaced by bkb_k (possibly times a phase factor) with Born's probability bkψ2|\langle b_k|\psi\rangle|^2. The question we investigate is: How well can any quantum experiment on the system determine afterwards whether a collapse has occurred? The answer depends on how much is known about the initial vector ψ\psi. We provide a number of different results addressing several variants of the question. In each case, no experiment can provide more than rather limited probabilistic information. In case ψ\psi is drawn randomly with uniform distribution over the unit sphere in Hilbert space, no experiment performs better than a blind guess without measurement; that is, no experiment provides any useful information.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.1307.0810,
  title  = {Can One Detect Whether a Wave Function Has Collapsed?},
  author = {Charles Wesley Cowan and Roderich Tumulka},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1307.0810},
  year   = {2014}
}

Comments

19 pages LaTeX, 8 figures. The first version of this paper has been (revised and) split into two papers, the first of which is v2 of this post, and the second part is posted as arXiv:1312.7321

R2 v1 2026-06-22T00:44:27.770Z