Better transmission with lower capacity: lossy compression over quantum channels

Shannon's channel coding theorem describes the maximum possible rate of reliable information transfer through a classical noisy communication channel. It, together with the source coding theorem, characterizes lossless channel communication in the classical regime. Lossy compression scenarios require the additional description provided by rate-distortion theory, which characterizes the trade-off between compression rate and the distortion of the compressed signal. Even in this context, the capacity characterizes the usefulness of a channel -- a channel with more capacity will always outperform a channel with less capacity. We show that this is no longer true when sending classical information over a quantum channel. In particular, we find a pair of quantum channels where the channel with the lower capacity causes less distortion than the higher capacity channel when both are used at a fixed rate.