Autolearn: Learn by Surprise, Commit by Proof

We propose Autolearn, a framework that enables language models to learn from documents they read, with no external supervision. Passages that produce anomalously high per-token loss are flagged, verified through a self-generated Q&A chain, and trained on with conviction-proportional $\beta_2$ adjustment. We introduce the perturbation gap (paraphrase-to-original perplexity ratio) as a metric that distinguishes memorization from understanding. The key mechanism is the training data format: Q&A-format training drives the perturbation gap below the pre-trained baseline (2.098 vs. 2.204, $\Delta = -0.106$, $> 10\sigma$), suppressing token-sequence memorization, while standard fine-tuning's best attempt remains within noise ($\Delta = -0.010$, $< 1\sigma$). Across four models spanning Qwen3 and Phi-4 families, Autolearn is the only method that enters this regime. Stochastic evaluation reveals passage-specific knowledge acquisition: the probability of generating a correct novel fact rises from 6% to 54% after training ($p < 10^{-4}$), and Q&A format outperforms standard fine-tuning on genuinely novel facts. The system is self-extinguishing: learned content reduces surprisal below threshold and is skipped on re-encounter.