English

Alternating knots do not admit cosmetic crossings

Geometric Topology 2022-01-03 v2

Abstract

By examining the homology groups of a 4-manifold associated to an integral surgery on a knot KK in a rational homology 3-sphere YY yielding a rational homology 3-sphere YY^* with surgery dual knot KK^*, we show that the subgroups generated by [K][K] and [K][K^*] in H1(Y)H_1(Y) and H1(Y)H_1(Y^*), respectively, have co-prime orders. We obtain an immediate corollary that, in conjunction with an argument of Lidman and Moore, proves the cosmetic crossing conjecture for knots whose branched double covers are Heegaard Floer L-spaces.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.2112.10980,
  title  = {Alternating knots do not admit cosmetic crossings},
  author = {Jacob Caudell},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:2112.10980},
  year   = {2022}
}

Comments

There is an error in the proof of the co-primality statement in Proposition 6. The author has constructed examples of knots with integer surgeries so that the orders of the groups generated by these knots and their surgery duals have a non-trivial common factor, so in fact the co-primality statement in Proposition 6 is false