English

A possible resolution of tension between {\it Planck} and Type Ia supernova observations

Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics 2013-12-31 v2 General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

Abstract

There is an apparent tension between cosmological parameters obtained from {\it Planck} cosmic microwave background radiation observations and that derived from the observed magnitude-redshift relation for the type Ia supernova (SNe Ia). Here, we show that the tension can be alleviated, if we first calibrate, with the help of the distance-duality relation, the light-curve fitting parameters in the distance estimation in SNe Ia observations with the angular diameter distance data of the galaxy clusters and then re-estimate the distances for the SNe Ia with the corrected fitting parameters. This was used to explore their cosmological implications in the context of the spatially flat cosmology. We find a higher value for the matter density parameter, Ωm\Omega_m, as compared to that from the original SNLS3, which is in agreement with {\it Planck} observations at 68.3%68.3\% confidence. Therefore, the tension between {\it Planck} measurements and SNe Ia observations regarding Ωm\Omega_m can be effectively alleviated without invoking new physics or resorting to extensions for the standard concordance model. Moreover, with the absolute magnitude of a fiducial SNe Ia, MM, determined first, we obtained a constraint on the Hubble constant with SNLS3 alone, which is also consistent with {\it Planck}.

Keywords

Cite

@article{arxiv.1311.3467,
  title  = {A possible resolution of tension between {\it Planck} and Type Ia supernova observations},
  author = {Zhengxiang Li and Puxun Wu and Hongwei Yu and Zong-Hong Zhu},
  journal= {arXiv preprint arXiv:1311.3467},
  year   = {2013}
}

Comments

12 pages, 3 figures, matches the vershion to be published in Science in China Series G