A comparison of different clustering approaches for high-dimensional presence-absence data

Presence-absence data is defined by vectors or matrices of zeroes and ones, where the ones usually indicate a "presence" in a certain place. Presence-absence data occur for example when investigating geographical species distributions, genetic information, or the occurrence of certain terms in texts. There are many applications for clustering such data; one example is to find so-called biotic elements, i.e., groups of species that tend to occur together geographically. Presence-absence data can be clustered in various ways, namely using a latent class mixture approach with local independence, distance-based hierarchical clustering with the Jaccard distance, or also using clustering methods for continuous data on a multidimensional scaling representation of the distances. These methods are conceptually very different and can therefore not easily be compared theoretically. We compare their performance with a comprehensive simulation study based on models for species distributions. This has been accepted for publication in Ferreira, J., Bekker, A., Arashi, M. and Chen, D. (eds.) Innovations in multivariate statistical modelling: navigating theoretical and multidisciplinary domains, Springer Emerging Topics in Statistics and Biostatistics.